A film review by Craig J. Koban
2008, PG-13, 122 mins.
2008, PG-13, 122 mins.
Bella Swan: Kristen Stewart / Edward Cullen: Robert Pattinson /
Charlie Swan: Billy Burke / Alice Cullen: Ashley Greene / Rosalie
Hale: Nikki Reed / Jasper Hale: Jackson Rathbone / Emmet
Cullen: Kellan Lutz
TWILIGHT is like an obtuse hybrid of Anne Rice meets Beverley Hills 90210 meets DAWSON ‘S CREEK. The film is simply too coy and silly to be scary or tense and far too cheaply melodramatic to be even modestly compelling. There is a seriously compelling story to be told here – that of a fairly timid and reserved teen girl that is seduced by and falls for a vampire – but TWILIGHT is pure cornball and too teenybopper chic for its own good. It’s penchant for going towards lame love story clichés, sappy daytime soap opera artifice, and giggle-inducing dialogue inevitably does it in. Instead of having a nicely understated eroticism with the themes, the film is cute and cuddly…
...but with adolescent angst!
The film is also very…odd. It is based on the enormously popular young adult horror-romance books by Stephenie Meyer and has vampires in it, but these bloodsuckers are never once truly fascinating creatures. Moreover, I never once truly understood the motives of these beings.
If you were a 107-year-old nausferatu that was doomed to live
forever as a 17-year-old and is made socially impotent by being around
normal flesh and blood humans...then why would you bother going to high school?
Furthermore, what would be the point of endlessly repeating the
same class and school experience indefinitely?
I would rather drive a steak through my own heart before repeating Grade
11 Physics over 100 times. As an immortal that craves human blood (but wants to learn to curb
a craving for it), what possible or plausible benefit is there for
sitting in a classroom daily surrounded by fresh human meat?
Would that not be like a struggling alcoholic hanging out in a bar
in hopes of kicking an addictive behavior?
Also…why do vampires need
to wait for a lightning storm to play recreational baseball?
Call me crazy, but the basic
universe of TWILIGHT doesn’t hold up for me.
I have no problem believing in the unbelievable in movies, but when
individual films can’t hold up to simple scrutiny within its own logical
rules, then I tune out. The
central problem with TWILIGHT is that I never once bought into why one of
the eternally damned personas would waste time with scholastic endeavors.
Not only that, but if you were a vampire, would you not want to
have a decent cover from society? Being
incredibly pale skinned, cold blooded, and having a Bela Legosi stare does
not lend itself to being inconspicuous.
Plus, if you’re trying real hard to not give into drinking human
blood, hanging out with young and fetching teen girls is not the best
It's bad enough having raging hormones, but adding a blood lust to
that? Not good.
It's bad enough having raging hormones, but adding a blood lust to that? Not good.
Alas, TWILIGHT does not believe in logic. It’s more secure in being a disposable action-romance for the 12-16-year-old girl sect. Like a sleazy Harlequin romance novel, the film is about lust, not forbidden love, as the trailers for the film may let on. There is no real tangible love between the two diametrically opposite young kids; instead, they are attracted by what each other represents. The teen vampire wants the girl in the worst way, but he torments himself about the meaning of “wanting.” Does he want her for lunch or to be his steady girlfriend? Frequently, he laments to her about how much he needs to be with her, but his appetite for sucking her dry means that – dammit! – he must stay aware from her. The young girl – for some inexplicable reason – instantly falls for this lad. As a matter of fact, she is willing to go so far with this super-humanly dangerous monster that she does not care about the repercussions. But why? Really? Why would a fairly bright and levelheaded teen want to potentially be cannibalized and left for dead by such a loser?
Maybe because he’s so…dreamy.
The plot is this:
17-year-old Bella (Kristen Stewart) has left her mom and stepdad
back in Arizona to come and live with her semi-estranged dad (Billy Burke)
in a cold and damp Pacific Northwest town.
Her dad is the Police Chief of the town in question (Forks,
Washington), which has a cozy population of 3100.
Despite the fact that things are initially awkward between daughter
and father, she does like being with him, mostly because he does not
“hover” over her all the time (as told in a completely unnecessary
voice over narration by Stewart).
Bella attends her first day
of class at a local high school and has the requisite run-ins with all of the
various cliques there. One
group of strangers, the Cullens, gets her to notice the most. They are seriously weird: most of them have skin so inhumanly light
and pale that its no wonder that a teacher has not intervened and sent
them to the nurses’ station for a check up.
Not only do they look really dead, but they also stare at people in
that zombified gaze that lends way too much attention.
How anyone would not suspect this clan to be bloodsuckers is beyond
One day in biology class
Bella has a very peculiar “meet cute” with one of the Cullen boys,
Edward (Robert Pattinson, perhaps most remembered for playing Cedric Diggory
in two HARRY POTTER films, and who will certainly have a career at making
teen girls swoon). Bella is
partnered with the very odd Edward for a bio-lab, but he exhibits
incredibly outlandish and bizarre behaviour around her.
Not only does he, as stated, look like a vampire, but he stares at
her so forcefully that he nearly breaks out into convulsions, almost like
he's having a seizure. This guy, to any reasonable young girl, either appears to be a coke
addict or a vampire, either of which would be bad news for any prospect of
a normal relationship. There seems to be no conceivable reason for Bella to become
smitten with this person. However,
he is played by the annoyingly handsome Pattinson, and he is simply too
unreservedly attractive to Bella, and the movie only reaffirms my
longstanding belief that cute girls will always choose the most handsome
and dangerous dude in the crowd that will cause her nothing but grief
instead of nice and well meaning boys that possess no threat whatsoever.
Despite their very odd introduction to one another, Bella and Edward seem drawn together. Edward exhibits the ultimate mixed singles to her: He frequently tells her that he wants to be by her at all times, but he can never be with her for undisclosed reasons. Bella falls for Edward because he maybe represents what she can’t have...I guess. Things get really dicey one morning when an out of control truck nearly slams into Bella. Edward saves her, in broad daylight and in front of hundreds of witnesses, by jumping in front of the truck and stopping it with his bare hands (conveniently, not one witness films footage of it on a camera phone, nor does anyone wonder why there is a hand-shaped dent in the vehicle). Bella, at least, starts to suspect that Edward is not normal. The film’s most insidiously and unintentionally funny beat occurs when she decides to do some research to discover Edward’s secret. She goes to the library, does some Google searches, which all culminates in a close up shot of her bugged out eyes with background music swelling to shocking crescendos: Like, ohmygawd, he’s like soooo a vampire. Now, any normal person would be able to discern with limited effort that Ed is a member of the undead. Yet, TWILIGHT operates so nauseatingly on the premise of “The Idiot Plot Syndrome” that it turns a smart character like Bella into a moron. Sigh.
Needless to say, the two
begin an obviously troublesome relationship, the kind where two people
want each other really bad regardless of the consequences.
Edward wants to love and have a respectful relationship with
Bella…buuuut he also struggles with whether to turn her into his next
meal. Bella, on the other
hand, does not seem to care (?) about being served up on a platter for
Edward’s ravenous cravings because…dammit…he’s dreamy.
Things go a bit smoother for the couple when Edward invites her
home to meet his family, where we learn that he and his clan are vegetarian
vamps, meaning that they eat only animals and not humans (good for Bella,
bad for PETA). Unfortunately,
just as things look like they are going to work out for Ed and Bella, a
truly dastardly and deadly non-vegetarian vampire named James shows up
that insatiably wants Bella to be his next victim.
Cam Gigandet plays James, the same actor who played a teen badass from NEVER
BACK DOWN. I still think that he is the love child of Brad
Pitt and Paul Walker.
Director Catherine Hardwicke
(THIRTEEN and THE LORDS OF DOGTOWN)
does manage to generate some thanklessly decent performances here.
Stewart in particular, who was memorable in films like INTO
THE WILD and PANIC ROOM, lends a grounded vulnerability and
low-key intensity to the otherwise ridiculous proceedings.
She is able to capture the awkward inflections of her guarded teen
character and embody her angst without it becoming overbearing:
She has a lovely, naturalistic screen presence.
Her scenes with her on-screen father have a sly charm and veracity.
I also appreciated how the teen characters polluting TWILIGHT are
played by age appropriate actors, which is a trend that I hope that other
adolescent-centric films will follow.
As much as I liked Stewart’s easy-going and affable presence in the film, the rest of TWILIGHT flounders around her. At $37 million dollars, the film is decidedly low budget…and it shows: Scenes with Edward and other vampires running up mountains, trees, and other terrain look egregious fake and flimsy. The climatic action set pieces pitting veggie-vamps versus flesh-hungry vamps is unremittingly a ho-hum affair that culminates too quickly and with little tension. It’s hard to drum up any level of excitement or dramatic tension here when TWILIGHT breaks a lot of movie laws when it comes to vampires. Nothing can really hurt these creatures (even when sun hits them, it makes their skin look like sparkling diamonds, which is beautiful to Bella). Seeing as vampires are mostly invulnerable in the film, they pretty much lack interest altogether.
And don’t get me started again on that whole vampire baseball
scrimmage? Why must they only
play during lightning storms? I’m
The villains themselves in
the film are so lacking in design, execution, and payoff that they inspired
more yawns then thrills. They
are almost a non-entity in the film and curiously show up when the script
deems it fitting. They are too loosely developed, as are a pair of enigmatic
and ill-defined supporting characters, two reservation Indian friends of
Bella and her father that – as far as my research goes – are supposed
to be werewolves, but its never satisfyingly dealt with in the film. I also did not quite understand why the villainous James
would waste his time searching for Bella to sink his teeth into when any
other mortal in the small town would suffice.
Were there no other attractive girls at the high school to become
his next unwitting victim?
The there is the Edward
character himself, as overplayed to the hilt at times by Pattinson,
sometimes to the point of laughable farce.
When the actor initially shows his inner torment while trying to
deal with what to do with Bella in that biology class, it’s so
unintentionally ham-infested and played with such obviousness by the actor
that one chuckles more than recoiling in terror.
He plays Edward as such a revolting sicko at first that it never
once feels likely that Bella would fall for this creep. It’s clear that Pattinson was hired for looks first and
talent a very distant second. A
lower key approach would have been so much more acceptable here with
Edward, but Pattinson’s work is too schizophrenic.
Of course, maybe my criticisms don’t matter. TWILIGHT is absolutely critic proof for its target teen demographic. The film has emerged as such a smash hit that plans for the sequel, NEW MOON, has already started. It’s too bad, because to the agnostic appreciator of Stephenie Meyer’s work, TWILIGHT emerges as a disposable and anaemic teenage romance that never really sinks its fangs into a memorable story. Perhaps even more unsettling is the central creepy and sleazy themes of the film, which is all the more unsettling considering the potentially young filmgoers that will flock to the flick: Lust for someone overwhelms all other emotional drives; if you want the person bad enough, the repercussions don’t matter at all. TWILIGHT has insatiable yearning between the boy and girl, but no real passion or affection. I mean, seriously...I ask again...why would Bella want to be with Edward? Does she want to be eaten and have her blood drank? Furthermore, has she never seen a vampire film? She must know how hopelessly depressing their lifestyles are, so why would the thought of becoming another member of the undead be so cool? Oh, right…because Edward is so damn dreamy…it would be a curse alone not to try to bed him. It’s funny, but for a film like this that claims to have elements of romance, love appears to be all-but-vacant.